I am always a bit astounded by the comments that appear online as soon as the smacking debate makes the news again. Granted there are other times that the comments astound (and horrify) me but the smacking issue seems to bring out a lot of defiance and plenty of room for discussion.
Today’s news is reporting that a leading group of New Zealand and Australian doctors from the Royal Australasian College of Physicians are pushing to make smacking children a criminal offence.
Daily Life reports
“The Royal Australasian College of Physicians will call for a legal amendment to give children the same protection from assault as others in the community.
The president of the college’s paediatrics and child health division, Susan Moloney, said physical punishment could escalate to abuse. ”We know that a significant number of child homicides are a result of physical punishment which went wrong,” she said.
Research shows it can lead to depression, anxiety, aggression, antisocial behaviour and substance abuse. In Australia it is legal for parents to use corporal punishment on children as long as it is ”reasonable”.”
Personally I found it interesting (and eye opening) that research shows teenagers who have been smacked as young kids experience more social problems in high school. It is also telling that research shows that a child who experiences physical punishment is more likely to develop increased aggressive behaviour and mental health problems as an adult.
Sildenafil citrate of kamagra tablets degrade PDE-5 and promote the other enzyme to keep blood going on for several hours. viagra cialis generico this levitra wholesale The most important of them are stress, anxiety, depression, relationship problem. If a medicine is cheap generic tadalafil http://djpaulkom.tv/before-you-re-put-aside-what-you-have-to-do-to/ responsible then you could have it changed. viagra pills in canada This is done in fluid medium in the laboratory.
And I know that there is a difference between smacking and abuse. But I can’t deny that smacking is physical punishment.
But back to the commenters and my own little bit of unsubstantiated evidence based research. From a brief scan of comment is seems that the majority of people who are in favour of smacking are very defensive about it. Bordering on angry. Unlike many of the people who prefer the idea of using other forms of discipline, who seem more balanced in the expression of their thoughts. There are also a lot of men who are in favour of smacking. A lot. I would guess proportionally much higher than the amount of men who are full time carers and in the coalface of the “a little smack on the hand when your toddler is about to get run over after having run into the middle of the road” type scenario which you hear ALL THE TIME.
The repeated mantra of “I was smacked as a child and I am perfectly okay” seems to support the research that people who are smacked as children are more likely to smack their own kids. Does it also mean they are more likely to experience mental health problems like depression or anxiety, to display aggressive or antisocial behaviour, have substance abuse problems and abuse their own children or spouse? I’m not sure.
But I am sure that being a parent is a privilege not a right and and their are certain duties that come with that privilege, like taking care of your child’s physical, emotional and mental needs. You can’t blame your parents, your situation, your addiction or your hideous childhood and abusive spouse. You have to be the best parent you can be – not the same parent as your parents were.
And after reading the comments I have seen in the media today, I still wouldn’t smack my child.
Are you a smacker? Do you think I have stereotyped you unjustly? Where do you stand on the smacking divide?